Coffee mugs with treats? - Jennifer Dittrich

That's exactly the sort of thing. - Jason P

If you want to get fun with it, there are paint pens you can get that are specifically for ceramics - so you could decorate the mugs with simple designs, or the person's initials or whatever. Another idea that I JUST saw that was cute - a beer stein with candies (like butterscotch candies) topped with marshmallows (looks like beer). - Laura

Dime bags. But i'll try and think on more legal options. - Steve C, Team Marina

homemade baked goods. with a bottle of beer. and a rub on tattoo. - Sir Shuping is just sir

or you can give them a tattoo! - Sir Shuping is just sir

Ha! I like the (temp) tattoo idea. I'm not qualified for the more permanent kind. - Jason P

These are great ideas, folks, thanks. Keep 'em coming. - Jason P

just do it with a permanent marker. it will eventually come off....mostly. - Sir Shuping is just sir

My mom gave all my high school friends coloring books, crayons, and those clips you hold bags of chips closed with for graduation. She became surprisingly popular. - laura x

Depending on the crowd, novelty condoms? - laura x

if they drink i used to buy a bottle of some really fancy beer/wee champagne thinger and go to the dollar store to get the most redonkulous cup you can find to go with it. - jambina

Wife got godiva chocolate ornament stars for $7 - MoTO Boychick Devil

DIY jam jar snow globes are easy and cheap: http://www.thesweetestoccasion.com/2012... - Soup in a TARDIS

Lip balm - t-ra: sentimental gorgon

Tacos. - Kristin

How about something like this? http://www.kirklands.com/product... It's a mini cast iron skillet that is meant to be used to bake a single cookie, along with the cookie mix. - April Russo (FForever!)

Those little chocolate bottles filled with real booze. - Laura Norvig